I haven't had a chance to make soap with this lovely FO yet, but couldn't resist sharing some OOB first impressions... I can count on one hand the number of times I've been in a B&BW store, so if I've ever smelled "Forever Red", I really can't recall, but I CAN say that the second I smelled this OOB, I thought, "Yup! This is definitely a scent I'd expect to smell at B&BW! It was a couple years ago, but my niece had actually requested that I make her a batch of soap that smelled like "Forever Red". Having no clue what it was SUPPOSED to smell like, I ordered a bottle from a well known wholesale soap supplier... And didn't care for it AT ALL. Figuring it was just a personal preference thing, I made soaps with it for my niece anyway. She thanked me for them, but politely told me that they didn't smell anything like "Forever Red" (OOPS! I really had no way of knowing, but I guess it wasn't an accurate dupe.). It REALLY hit me today tho what this FO smells like!! The last time I placed an order with a different supplier located in WA., they had just recently released a FO called "Rose Gold"... To my nose, this FO smells just about identical to that FO, which confirms to me this must be a spot-on representation of "Forever Red", considering they also carry a FO called "Rose Quartz" that's totally "Love Spell", and one called "Moonstone" that smelled identical to a dupe of "Moonlit Path" I once had. I can't wait to make a batch of CP for my niece with this FO & finally redeem myself lol! Plus, with how unbelievably spot-on EVERY duplication FO I've ever purchased here is, I'm pretty confident this is the "Forever Red" she wanted! It's a lovely aroma... Sweet and softly floral with a beautiful and cozy vanilla & cashmere-type base! It's feminine and sexy... A scent I could see young ladies really enjoying, but not reserved for just one age group either- I can see this being enjoyed by MANY! It's a lovely & elegant scent with s splash of sexy & a dash of cozy sweet!